Opera Overview: three Tudor Queens, Each With Her Very own Sad Ending

September 17th, 2013

CARDIFF, Wales — Donizetti never ever considered of his a few operas about Tudor queens as a trilogy and scarcely any person else did possibly till the soprano Beverly Sills sang them at the New York City Opera in the nineteen seventies. Each with a libretto by a diverse creator, they had been premiered in excess of a 7-12 months period (1830-1837) in distinct Italian theaters, with various singers as the royal protagonists: Giuditta Pasta (“Anna Bolena”), Maria Malibran (“Maria Stuarda”) and Giuseppina Ronzi de Begnis (Elizabeth I in “Roberto Devereux”).

Robert Workman

The soprano Serena Farnocchia faces rejection, dying and momentary insanity in the Welsh National Opera creation of ‘‘Anna Bolena.’’

A sortable calendar of noteworthy cultural occasions in the New York location, picked by Times critics.

Robert Workman

The soprano, Adina Nitescu,  in her part as Queen Elizabeth I in ‘‘Maria Stuarda.’’  

The tales, common from the two history and literary fabrications, are significantly apart chronologically. Yet each and every culminates in an execution — Anne Boleyn’s in 1536 at the behest of her spouse, Henry VIII, for, amongst other things, alleged infidelity Mary Stuart’s in 1587 because of the menace she posed to Elizabeth I’s rule and Robert Devereux’s in 1601, for treason. At the coronary heart of every single plot are one particular or a lot more really like triangles, regardless of whether rooted in fact or invented.

Authentic or not, the Tudor Trilogy is happily with us, for these are fine operas. Selecting a favored is not simple — mine tends to be the a single I have encountered most lately in a convincing overall performance. As with Wagner’s “Ring,” opera companies often mount the personal operas steadily, but the intrepid Welsh Countrywide Opera, now in its third period underneath the noted phase director David Pountney’s leadership, is at the moment introducing them in new productions at the Wales Millennium Center inside of the area of just a thirty day period. “Anna Bolena” and “Maria Stuarda” are now in repertory, with “Roberto Devereux” to follow on Oct. 7.

The bold timetable imposes challenges on the company’s creation and musical capabilities, from which it does not emerge unscathed, but the stress is lessened by having the very same set serve for all a few operas — a practical black box designed by Madeleine Boyd. She also created the prevailingly black costumes, which have particulars suggestive each of Tudor and of more current occasions. In addition, duties are shared by two administrators and two conductors: Alessandro Talevi and Daniele Rustioni for “Anna Bolena” and “Roberto Devereux,” Rudolf Frey and Graeme Jenkins for “Maria Stuarda.”

Only two figures, Elizabeth I and her stern adviser, William Cecil, look in more than one opera. But Mr. Talevi’s powerful staging ingeniously permits Elizabeth to look in all 3 operas by demonstrating her mom, Anne Boleyn, in the aftermath of giving beginning to the foreseeable future monarch at the start off of “Anna Bolena.” Not only does this introduce us to the girl whose dictates dominate the succeeding operas, but the situation of Elizabeth’s illegitimate beginning is introduced to the fore.

Prior to her marriage, Anne was betrothed to Henry Percy, information of which enrages the operatic Henry by casting question on the legitimacy of his relationship to Anne and — as he alludes to in words and phrases that are easily ignored — also reflecting adversely on his infant daughter.

It all constitutes telling preparing for the renowned (if fictionalized) confrontation among the two queens in “Maria Stuarda,” when Mary, held as Elizabeth’s prisoner and tormented outside of stamina by her insults, denounces her publicly as “the sullied daughter of Boleyn” and a “vile bastard.” Unfortunately, Mr. Frey’s staging falls short of undertaking that opera justice. Within the black-box set, yet another box serves as Mary’s prison mobile Elizabeth seems in it dejectedly at the finish, thereby drawing a parallel in between the two queens. But the unit does not aid the motion, which is marred in other places by this sort of interruptions as Mary smoking a cigarette in her entrance aria and an uncomfortable foot-washing episode throughout the relocating scene in which Mary’s supporter, George Talbot, gets her confession according to Catholic tenets.

Musically, way too, “Anna Bolena” will come off better. The soprano Serena Farnocchia may possibly not be the most charismatic of Annas, but her singing is persistently appealing and, in facing rejection, death and short-term madness, she deals with Anna’s frustrating last scene grippingly, often couched in Elizabeth’s crib.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.