Dance Assessment: ‘The Sleeping Beauty’ at the Paris Opera Ballet

December 23rd, 2013

S?bastien Math?/Op?ra nationwide de Paris

The Sleeping Beauty Josua Hoffalt and Ludmila Pagliero in the Paris Opera Ballet generation of this classic fantasy.

PARIS — Rudolf Nureyev’s “The Sleeping Beauty,” currently becoming executed by the Paris Opera Ballet, is ornate, ceremonious and very, extremely long. It also hints at Nureyev’s ambivalence towards the Russia he left powering when he defected to the West in 1961 at 23 although on tour with the Kirov Ballet.

It was for the Kirov that “The Sleeping Beauty” was produced in 1890, when the firm was referred to as (as it is once again now) the Mariinsky Ballet. Its choreographer was the French-born Marius Petipa its composer, Tchaikovsky. In its formal perfection, its reiteration of hierarchical get and its grand theme of good vs . evil, “The Sleeping Beauty” represents the summit of balletic classicism. It remained a preoccupation for Nureyev during his profession.

He initial staged it at 28 for La Scala, then for several other firms just before bringing it to the Paris Opera in 1989 in his last year as creative director there. Nureyev’s “Beauty,” now being carried out by the Paris business for the first time in 9 years, is packed with pomp and ceremony, with Baroque court dances and decorous formations of courtiers and royals, fairies and dryads. Its d?cor, by Ezio Frigerio, is luxurious, with classical columns and reclining nudes embellished by Rococo element the costumes, by Franca Squarciapino, are an excessively lovely riot of colour and gold braid.

Does the ballet convey Nureyev’s admiration for the pre-Soviet times of imperial splendor and the way that ballet alone demonstrates the social get of the royal court docket? Or was he, as the Paris Opera plan implies, supplying “subtle criticism of energy and its maintain more than the individual”?

Each might be correct the elaborate excesses of the ballet seem to be at once a veneration of the absolute authority of royal energy and immutable social order, but also so exaggerated that it is challenging not to think about that a contact of irony pervades the display. But one factor is distinct: It is occurring extremely slowly.

There is in no way one variation, if two or a few will do, and the spectacular substantial factors — Carabosse’s curse on the infant Aurora, the second when the younger princess pricks her finger, the prince’s arrival at the sleeping castle — are oddly muted by the leisurely staging and the decision to all but abolish the explanatory mime. They are also dampened by practically nonexistent performing moderate shock seemed to be the emotion of selection at a functionality this month, whether a curse to the death, or unexpected salvation from exact same, was in the offing.

The lack of dramatic impulse was exacerbated by the tempo of the rating, conducted by Fay?al Karoui and performed by the Paris Opera orchestra at tempos that ranged from lethargic to funereal. (This must be very odd for Mr. Karoui, the Paris company’s musical director, who beforehand held the identical situation at the New York City Ballet. There, the “Sleeping Beauty” staged by Peter Martins would have been earlier the midway mark when Nureyev’s eighty-moment 1st act was just ending.)

And Nureyev’s selection to use the Lilac Fairy (Juliette Gernez, in this generation) as a mime counterpart to Carabosse (Nolwenn Daniel), fairly than as a dancing fairy, further handicaps the narrative. It is the choreography that spots the Lilac Fairy as a heart of electricity and relaxed authority. Without having it, she just looks to be an sophisticated girl in a nice purple dress, and the wrestle between excellent and evil that is one of the ballet’s central motifs by no means emerges with any clarity.

Nor, in the functionality of Ludmila Pagliero as Aurora, does the ballet’s other excellent concept grow to be obvious: the maturing of the adolescent princess into a lady by way of the ordeal of the curse, and her one hundred-year slumber. The Argentine-born Ms. Pagliero, who did not teach at the Paris Opera Ballet, has a solid-iron technique, as effectively as a beautiful, buoyant leap and exquisitely arched toes.

She is a lot more French than the French in this ballet, her arabesques not often greater than a ninety-degree angle, her footwork impeccably glowing, her demeanor demure. When she relaxes, as she did in her second Act I solo, into a a lot more lush, expansive presence, she comes to existence with thrilling vibrancy.

But Ms. Pagliero does not at any time present the way Aurora grows into adulthood by way of dance. Her Aurora is mature and assured from the commence, without having the mystique that should attract Prince D?sir? (Josua Hoffalt) to the eyesight that the Lilac Fairy demonstrates him in Act II. When this Aurora is woke up with a kiss, she looks minor different from her confident self of 100 years before there has been no transformation.

“The Sleeping Beauty” operates by means of Jan. four at the Bastille Opera in Paris operadeparis.fr.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.